Costly Medicare Mistakes You Should Avoid Making

TL;DR

Prime Big Deal Days · Oct 6–7Offer from Amazon

Get health and wellness essentials delivered free — and shop member deals

• Fast, free delivery on millions of items
• Access to Prime Big Deal Days deals on October 6–7
• Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included

Start your free Prime trial →Free trial for eligible customers · Cancel anytime

As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.Hide

A Seniors Guide report identifies five Medicare decisions that can lead to higher costs or coverage problems: failing to review drug plans, choosing a spouse’s plan by default, using out-of-network care, missing plan-change periods and delaying a Medigap choice. Plan rules, prices and enrollment rights vary, so beneficiaries should verify details for their location and circumstances.

A Seniors Guide report highlights five Medicare choices that can expose beneficiaries to higher prescription costs, out-of-network bills or enrollment penalties: leaving drug coverage unreviewed, selecting the same Part D plan as a spouse without comparing needs, using providers outside a Medicare Advantage network, overlooking opportunities to switch plans, and delaying a Medigap decision. The report urges beneficiaries to compare coverage and check plan rules, while noting that options and protections depend on the plan, state and individual circumstances.

Medicare Part D and Medicare Advantage plans can change their premiums, drug cost-sharing, covered medications and pharmacy arrangements from year to year, according to the report. It identifies the annual enrollment period from October 15 through December 7 as a time to compare options. The Medicare Plan Finder can be used to enter medications and dosages and estimate premiums and out-of-pocket drug costs for plans available in a person’s area.

The report says spouses should compare Part D plans separately rather than assume they will save by enrolling together: there are no spousal discounts, and their medications may differ. It also cautions that a plan’s preferred pharmacy network can affect prices. For Medicare Advantage, provider networks matter because some plans offer limited or no routine out-of-network coverage. The report recommends checking with both the insurer and providers to confirm whether doctors and facilities will be in-network for the coming year.

Beneficiaries enrolled in Medicare Advantage have another annual opportunity to change plans or return to Original Medicare from January 1 through March 31, the report says. Certain circumstances, including moving outside a plan’s service area, may permit a special enrollment period. It also warns that Medigap access can become more restricted after an initial six-month period tied to enrollment in Part B: in most states, insurers may then reject applicants or charge more based on health, subject to state rules and other protections.

How Plan Choices Affect Costs

The financial consequences can extend beyond a monthly premium. A plan with a low premium may have less favorable coverage for a person’s prescriptions, require a specific pharmacy, or leave preferred doctors outside its network. Failing to check these details can mean higher medication costs or reduced access to providers, though the actual impact depends on the person’s plan and care needs.

Timing also matters. Missing an enrollment deadline can limit when someone can change coverage, and the report warns that some mistakes may lead to penalties or gaps. Medigap decisions can carry particular significance because guaranteed access may be time-limited under federal rules, while state-specific protections can differ. Reviewing coverage before deadlines gives beneficiaries a chance to compare choices rather than discover costs after care or prescriptions are needed.

Medicare’s Annual Review Windows

The report focuses on two recurring enrollment windows. The general annual enrollment period, October 15 to December 7, is when people can review and make certain changes to Medicare coverage, including Part D and Medicare Advantage plans. The separate Medicare Advantage open enrollment period runs from January 1 to March 31 and offers people already enrolled in Medicare Advantage an opportunity to change plans or return to Original Medicare.

These windows do not cover every situation. The report says qualifying life changes can trigger special enrollment rights, and that a five-star Medicare Advantage plan may be available to join at other times under the rules it describes. Medigap policies supplement Original Medicare; enrollment rights and switching protections depend on federal and state provisions. Medicare.gov and state insurance departments are cited as sources for local plan and policy information.

““If you’ve been prescribed new medications or your drugs have gone generic over the past year, a different plan may now be a better deal for you.””

— Seniors Guide report

Rules Vary by State and Plan

The report does not provide a person-specific estimate of potential savings or costs; those depend on location, prescriptions, providers, plan terms and care needs. It also does not list the plans available to individual readers or confirm whether a particular doctor, hospital or pharmacy will be covered in a future plan year. Beneficiaries should verify network participation and coverage directly with the insurer and provider.

Medigap switching rights are not uniform across states, and the report’s general description does not identify every exception to underwriting or guaranteed-issue rules. Special enrollment eligibility also depends on individual circumstances. Readers should check current details with Medicare, their state insurance department or a qualified benefits counselor before changing coverage.

Check Coverage Before Deadlines

Beneficiaries can use the Medicare Plan Finder to compare local options, entering current medications and dosages to estimate drug costs. They should also check that doctors, hospitals and pharmacies are included in a plan’s network and confirm any changes with the insurer before enrolling. People considering Medigap can review state protections through their state insurance department and consult Medicare.gov for policy information.

The next step depends on the coverage at issue: the annual enrollment period recurs each fall, while the Medicare Advantage open enrollment period runs from January 1 through March 31. Anyone who has moved or experienced another qualifying change should check promptly whether a special enrollment period applies. The report gives general guidance, not individualized advice, and plan terms and enrollment rules should be confirmed for the current year.

Key Questions

When can I review or change Medicare coverage?

The report lists October 15 to December 7 as the annual enrollment period for reviewing options, including Part D and Medicare Advantage. People already enrolled in Medicare Advantage also have a change period from January 1 to March 31. Other opportunities may apply in qualifying circumstances; check Medicare’s current rules.

Should spouses choose the same Part D plan?

Not automatically. The report says there are no spousal discounts and spouses may take different medications. Each person can compare their prescriptions, dosages, pharmacy options and estimated costs using the Medicare Plan Finder.

Why check my Medicare Advantage provider network?

Medicare Advantage plans generally use provider networks, and out-of-network care may have less coverage or higher costs. The report recommends confirming with both the insurer and providers that doctors and facilities will be included for the coming year.

Can I switch Medigap plans whenever I want?

Not necessarily. The report says people generally have a six-month period after enrolling in Part B to buy a Medigap plan with broader access regardless of preexisting conditions. Later switching protections vary by state and circumstances, so check state rules and Medicare.gov.

Source: rss